Mosaic Freeschool

  • Home
  • Classes
    • On Site Classes '25-'26
    • Past Classes
  • Facilitators
    • Mosaic Facilitators
    • Educator Network
  • Enrollment
    • Admissions
    • Registration
    • Payment
  • Contact
  • Opportunities
  • Home
  • Classes
    • On Site Classes '25-'26
    • Past Classes
  • Facilitators
    • Mosaic Facilitators
    • Educator Network
  • Enrollment
    • Admissions
    • Registration
    • Payment
  • Contact
  • Opportunities

Mosaic Minutes

Foundations of Philosophy Class Summaries 11/11 & 11/18/13

11/22/2013

 
with Sally Zeiner

November 11

PictureWings
This week in philosophy class we revisited the issues of ethics and identity through the events of Wings and Bigger than the Baker's Boy.

Question 1: Ethics

Cyril says that “stealing is stealing even if you've got wings.” Jane argues that no one scolds the birds, and then they go on to eat “quite as many plums as were good for them.” However, when Jane sees the man, she says, “We had some of your plums; we thought it wasn’t stealing, but now I am not so sure.” Later in the day, they feel that it is right to take the necessities of life from the clergyman, until they find themselves locked on the roof. Then, they begin once again to think that their actions are wrong.

Do you think they were wrong to eat the clergyman’s food? How do you know when something is wrong?

What kind of knowing is this?

Was Robert wrong when he lassoed the baker’s boy? What about when he put him on the roof of the cowshed?

Was it wrong to go to the fair as a giant to make money?

The class worked to develop a criteria for right and wrong that can be applied in many situations, rather than simply stating an opinion of the ethics of each individual case. One budding philosopher articulated that it is the knowledge and willingness of the participants in each event that determine whether something is right or wrong. Another student of philosophy developed the term prehenceive: a preexisting law, something that has been set in stone for as long as anyone can remember; it is almost a sixth sense, something that you know you can or can't do. Similar ideas can be found in the work of Plato.

Question 2: Identity


Was Robert still Robert when he was a giant? Why or why not?

What is your criterion for identity? Has it changed?

Homework: Write your criterion for identity and bring it next week. What makes you you? Is your identity independent of the world around you, or does it depend on the world around you?

Next week we will review our criteria for identity before we discuss chapters 15 and 16 from The Wonderful Wizard of Oz.


November 18

Picture
Before we discussed the The Wonderful Wizard of Oz in class this week, we tried a few experiments in perception, taken from Philosophy for Kids. We also discussed Kant's position that for us to know something there must be both an objective reality and a subjective experience of that reality.

You might enjoy trying these at home:

Reality

Look at an object placed on the table. Describe the (a) size, (b) shape, and (c) color without looking at your neighbors answers.

A.

B.

C.

Now list them on the chalkboard. Are the answers all the same? Discuss.

How you do know what you know?

Do you know 2 + 2 = 4? How do you know?

a.     It feels right when I look at it.

b.     I learned arithmetic in the first grade.

c.      I realize it can be proven using universally accepted mathematical principles.

Picture
You are holding a ripe, red apple. How do you know that it is red?

a.      Because I can clearly see its redness.

b.      Because everyone calls this color “red.”

c.      Because I can see that it is red – and it is red.


Next week we will begin discussing The Little Prince. Students should read through section VIII, and write down one or two different issues in the book that strike them as philosophical. We will discuss these in class.


Comments are closed.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Afternoon Enrichment
    Closures
    Clubs
    Early Elementary
    Mosaic Texas
    Odyssey Of The Mind
    Out Of This World
    Philosophy
    Tesserae Fall 2012
    Tesserae Fall 2013
    Tesserae Fall 2014
    Tesserae Spring 2013
    Tesserae Spring 2014
    Tesserae Spring 2015
    Tesserae Spring 2016

    Archives

    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012

Proudly powered by Weebly
Photos from nojhan, Clay Gilliland, mynameisharsha, kim siciliano salem, matthewvenn, photogirl7.1, El Bibliomata, ~Brenda-Starr~, Anne Worner, Heather Bickle, NASA Goddard Photo and Video, Black.Dots., marta.b, Felipe Venâncio, A. Galassi, bibliojojo, Bibliothèque - Les Champs Libres - Rennes, Robert Hensley, opensourceway, Greenland Travel, est1996x, John-Morgan, camnjeanacess, plindberg, chrisjtse, Vox Efx, philosophygeek, utpala ॐ, Cea., Phil Roeder, andreazgarcia, stevecadman, laynasaur, Steve A Johnson, mattk1979, Tattooed Hippy, spacepleb, Mateus Hidalgo, Todd Binger, TRF_Mr_Hyde, ComputerHotline, Hampshire and Solent Museums, Ben Sutherland, philip_sheldrake, WeeLittlePiggy, echiner1, gruntzooki, emmeffe6, saoire, symphony of love, ups2006, Dave_B_, bobsfever, Kelly Short6, RichardBH, frau-Vogel, Skype Nomad, giopuo, Tomi Tapio